The Pentagon is preparing its own criminal case against Lt Gen Brett Sylvia, whom Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth removed as the Joint Staff’s head of planning in late October on the accusation that he leaked classified information to journalists. The Washington Post, citing an anonymous official, reported the development on Sunday, November 15. The Trump administration has told the armed forces to consider a military prosecution, which would mean Sylvia faces both the Pentagon and the Justice Department. The official said the case was assigned to acting Army Secretary Adam Telle “for appropriate disposition”.
The same official claimed that Sylvia admitted to military investigators that he kept notes from classified government documents and gave information from them to a journalist. He also allegedly contacted a reporter over the Signal app and deleted the conversation. The Justice Department did not confirm that it is investigating the general. In a brief statement to the paper it said only that it has “ongoing investigations into possible leaks of classified information” and works closely with “our government partners”, the Pentagon among them.
Sylvia was director of Strategy, Plans and Policy (J5) on the Joint Staff and was removed on October 28 without an official reason, as we reported at the time. The next day chief Pentagon spokesman Sean Parnell wrote on X that the Department of War has “zero tolerance for the deliberate, unauthorised disclosure of classified information”, spoke of an “extensive investigation” by the Air Force Office of Special Investigations (OSI) and said the case had been referred to the Justice Department, without naming the general. A statement from a “Department of War official” circulated to the media accused Sylvia, according to Military.com, of “serious misconduct”, of leaks about the war with Iran and the Russia-Ukraine war, and said he failed three polygraph tests. It added that, because journalists must be escorted inside the building, the general met reporters outside the Pentagon.
The accusations have not been proved. Two other Pentagon sources told CBS News that the removal is linked to the polygraph examinations but disputed that the general leaked classified information. Sylvia did not respond to the network’s request for comment. National security lawyers argue that releasing the polygraph results may violate the Privacy Act of 1974. Sylvia is a decorated officer with a Purple Heart and six Bronze Stars, and until May 2025 he commanded the 101st Airborne Division.
Experts in military justice told the Washington Post that involvement by Hegseth’s team could create legal problems, because the system is designed to operate without interference from senior officials. If the case proceeds, a general will be appointed to decide impartially whether to refer it to a court-martial, where eight officer jurors senior to him in rank would decide. Franklin Rosenblatt, a retired Army officer and law professor, told the paper that the aim may not be a conviction but deterring others from leaking: “the process is the punishment”. Beyond sharing classified material, he said, Sylvia could be charged with violating a lawful order or regulation, conduct unbecoming an officer and contemptuous words against senior civilian officials.




